NightAntilli
Well-Known Member
Oh I never said LIS was perfect. And it's quite obvious you dislike Max so much that you want to kill her in every ending lol. Many people disliked the ending choice, but I thought it was fine. For me, the life of one was not worth the whole town, so, I let Chloe die, like she was supposed to from the beginning. No ending is fully satisfactory, and it's supposed to be like that. Some people don't like it, and that's fine. But we have been pampered too much in video games to have only heroic endings.For here, I'll keep it brief: I did finish the game, which is how I know that it handles its themes of consequence, bullying, and entropy in abysmal fashion. The characters are unlikable until the very end. The problem with sacrificing everyone for Chloe is that Chloe and Max don't die. The problem with sacrificing Chloe is that Max and everyone else don't die. It's sort of like the ending of Mass Effect, except we only get two colors and both of them are undesirable for the wrong reasons (and you have to let go of any head-canon involving the consequences of any other decisions you made). As someone who touted Dragon Age: Origins' storytelling, you obviously have exposure to how this can be done better.
After playing Before the Storm, Chloe is very likeable compared to the original, and Rachel is amazingly loveable. Is even Kate unlikable?You are also expected to care about people for no reason, and since they fail to provide good reasons, this makes me utterly apathetic to the decisions about their fate and circumstance. They were obviously touching on depression, but it's a pretty bad way to handle it when you're depressed because you're a bland piece of shit who somehow remains that way despite being blessed with deus ex machina powers for no fucking reason. I'm aware that there are some people who believe that all life is precious, and if you ascribe to that philosophy you can probably find some merit here. But I do not. I value stories that focus on people who are exceptional in some way of their own doing, not characters who are blessed by fortune. You can have fortune befall you, but there has to be something extraordinary about the individual and what they do with that fortune for me to care. Max doesn't do anything remarkable except having magic powers. Take those away and she's nothing.
Yeah. We get it. You hate Max. And that's fine. She's as normal and boring as can be, and she was designed that way on purpose. The whole point of the "fortune" of max was that it wasn't a fortune at all, hence the unsatisfactory ending. Well, I guess it's simply not your thing. This is a game about life drama, not heroism.
The ninjas have a direct correlation between their style and their story. Most of the rest of the cast have a fighting style, just because. And that's another reason DOA's story sucks.While I do think that if DOA had more consistent characterizations then it may influence your choice(s) more strongly, I also believe that fighting styles are tied to story-telling (if it's done properly). A proper story would give Leifang redeemable traits outside of her visual fighting style, and you would probably appreciate that addition. But conversely, if they added a character you adored a great deal (such as in DBZ), I can imagine you would play that character a good amount even if you considered their visual fighting style less impressive than to Lei's.
Tina is a wrestler because her father is. Bass is a wrestler because....?
Jann Lee has JKD because he was an orphan living in poverty that apparently had enough time and money to watch enough martial arts on TV to learn it. Yeah right. Not buying it.
Leifang has Taiji Quan because she's Chinese and had her ego stamped on by Jann Lee. Meh.
Helena has piquaquan because...?
Kokoro has bajiquan because it's symbolic in correlation to Helena being her half-sister, and the styles being 'sisters' as well. Meh..
Zack has muay thai because...?
Hitomi has Karate because her father taught her.
Not going to tackle everyone... But it's quite obvious that this is all extremely shallow.
And yes, if they add a character I like (I would love to beat you with Max from Life Is Strange LOL!!), I will play it. Inevitably, it's not hard for other characters to have more interesting back-stories than the ones from DOA.