I dislike it because it derives too much from the originals, and IMO they really messed up the controls it really doesn't play well I'd take SH3 anyday over Homecoming/Downpour
I can agree with you on Downpour. I'm a huge wuss with horror games and even I can play that.
Homecoming had so many subtleties and scary moments that it really left an impression on me. The dodging was nice. It took a little bit of the suspense out of fighting, but the controls were still so bad that you really wanted to run away from anything you could.