Yeah, that was basically how I was reading it too."It's like boxing with a tornado".
Understand that every frame trap Pai has tells you on an educated level that you need to block and be patient, but if you do that you're never going to be able to attack. She can just loop the frame advantage indefinitely. Most intelligent players will still tell you to be patient, but logic would dictate you have to.
If we had throw breaks, I would say that maybe it's the smart choice. But we don't.
Against Pai, you HAVE to make a move while at disadvantage, even though probability dictates that you will lose the majority of the time. So when you are saying you had the most success with hold-izunas, you were basically on the right track. To block is to lose -- you are simply delaying the inevitable and not putting yourself in any better of a position to win. You have to hold, step, fuzzyguard, whatever is necessary at that exact point in time. But you can never just block.
To block is to lose.
A stance that parries mid/high punches, frame advantage mixed with super-speed, holds and throws that lead into guaranteed follow-ups, great mix-ups, great crushes, etc. Makes you feel like there's never a "good" option you can take beyond guessing the EXACT step she will take next, which given her perpetually high amount of options is extraordinarily hard to do.
I feel she's heavily underrated. The "Official Tier List" puts her at 4-6 with Bayman, and 5-5 with Bass, Brad and Ryu. Something about that just doesn't feel right to me.